All articles
compliance · HVHZ

Large missile vs. small missile: which impact rating does your opening need?

“Impact-rated” on a product sheet is half an answer. The other half is which missile the rating was earned against — and the Florida Building Code decides that for you by elevation, not preference. Get the class wrong and the approval is real, the product is good, and the submittal still bounces.

A stylized 3D window panel struck by a 2×4 timber missile and small steel balls, with lime-green motion trails on a deep navy background

The short version

  • Openings at or below 30 feet (9.1 m) above grade need the large missile rating — FBC Building, Section 1626.2.
  • Openings above 30 feet need the small missile rating — Section 1626.3.
  • A large-missile rating usually covers both classes, because of the 3/16-inch exception in TAS 201-94 — but a small-missile-only rating never covers the ground zone.
  • Risk Category IV essential facilities follow the large missile everywhere: 80 ft/s within 30 feet, 50 ft/s above.

Two missiles, two different events

The two classes are not a medium and a large version of the same hit. They are different projectiles, different speeds, and different test sequences.

  • Large missile — a nominal 2×4 timber weighing 9 pounds (4.1 kg), driven at 50 ft/s (80 ft/s for essential facilities, per Section 1626.2.4). Each specimen takes two impacts: one near the center, one in a corner.
  • Small missile — solid steel balls of 2 grams, about 5/16 inch in diameter, launched at 130 ft/s. Each specimen takes thirty impacts, in groups of ten across three zones.

Both run through the same protocol family — the impact plus the cyclic pressure sequence that follows, TAS 201 and TAS 203 against the Table 1626 gust schedule. The distinction is not which lab ran the test; it is which missile that specimen had to survive.

The 30-foot line is a code rule, not a product choice

Section 1626.2.1 applies the large-missile test to assemblies used “up to and including 30 feet (9.1 m) in height in any and all structures.” Section 1626.3.1 applies the small-missile test “above 30 feet.” The code draws the line; you do not.

The practical consequence on a mid-rise: the ground floor and typically the second floor sit in the large-missile band, and the floors above are small-missile. Same facade, two different ratings, and the product that sailed through plan review on the third floor may not be approved at the first.

Why the line sits at 30 feet: the hurricane debris field stratifies. Heavy debris — fencing, roof members, construction lumber — stays low, which is what the 2×4 simulates. Small, light debris — gravel and roof ballast carried by a mature wind field — gets lifted high, which is what the 2-gram ball simulates. Section 1626 is the code’s way of dividing those two environments.

The risk-category override

Risk Category IV essential facilities skip the happy path. Within 30 feet, the large missile speeds up: 80 ft/s instead of 50 (Section 1626.2.4). Above 30 feet, they drop the small missile entirely and take the large missile at 50 ft/s (Section 1626.3.1).

That matters on any project with a hospital wing, fire or police station, emergency operations center, or designated shelter — which in South Florida means a large share of public buildings. On one of those, a small-missile-only product is not eligible anywhere, at any height.

The exception that lets one rating cover both

TAS 201-94, Section 6.3.2.3 states it directly: a specimen that passes the large missile test does not need the small missile test if it has no opening that a 3/16-inch sphere can pass through.

In plain terms: a fully sealed assembly that survived the 2×4 is presumed to survive the steel balls, because for that specimen the 2×4 is the harder event. That is why most residential and storefront impact products carry a large missile — or “both” — rating on the approval.

But the exception has a hole, and the hole is exactly the assemblies with real openings: operable vents, louvers, and louvered shutters. If the product has an opening a 3/16-inch sphere can pass, the large-missile pass no longer carries the small-missile class — the approval must show both independently.

So read the approval, not the brochure. A product advertised as “impact-rated” may carry only small-missile coverage — perfect for the third floor, wrong for the first. Reading a Miami-Dade NOA field by field shows you where the missile class and speed actually appear.

What to check before you order

  1. Pull the elevation band off the drawings. Each opening’s height above grade decides its class. The product data sheet does not.
  2. Confirm the risk category. If the project is Risk Category IV, small-missile coverage is irrelevant — look for the large missile, and check the speed: 80 ft/s within 30 feet, 50 ft/s above.
  3. Match the missile class on the approval to the band. Large-missile products typically cover both classes through the 3/16-inch exception; small-missile-only products are confined to above 30 feet.
  4. Check the speed column. “Impact-rated” with no speed is not a claim you can build a submittal on. 50 vs. 80 ft/s is the difference between a storefront window and an emergency-room window.

The missile class is one input to an approval that also has to cover the design pressure, the substrate, and the anchorage at that specific opening. That is why the fastest way to lose the argument is to let “impact-rated” carry weight it never had. To keep every check on one list, the window submittal package checklist is where to start.

And if matching every opening on every elevation against its approval band is eating the week — that is exactly the kind of repeated, rule-based check a structured compliance workflow is built to carry.